HSCprep Team
March 26, 2025
77 min read
Getting an exam or assessment back can stir up a mix of emotions – relief if you did well, disappointment if you didn't. But what you do next with that marked paper is even more important than the mark itself.
Unfortunately, many students make the mistake of glancing at their score, feeling either complacent or discouraged, and then shoving the paper in a folder never to be looked at again.
In fact, one education expert defined feedback as information about the gap between your current and desired performance that "is considered as feedback only when it is used to alter the gap."
In other words, if you don't use those teacher comments and marking cues to change something about your approach, you're engaging in passive reception (and likely stagnation). Sadly, studies find many students don't use the feedback they receive and thus "do not realize the potential of feedback for learning".
So, what separates the students who improve from those who don't? It's all about taking an active, strategic approach to feedback – much like active learning versus passive learning. Just as re-reading notes on autopilot (passive) won't boost your HSC results as much as self-quizzing or teaching others (active learning), simply reading your teacher's comments won't magically raise your next exam mark. You need to engage with that feedback: dissect it, question it, and do something about it.
It's a skill that top students consistently practice, and one you can learn too.
In this article, we'll break down how to use teacher or marker feedback after any exam or assessment to help your future performance. We'll cover why feedback matters, and then dive into 10 actionable strategies – from deciphering marking criteria and making an action plan, to adopting a growth mindset about criticism.
By the end, you should have a clear game plan for turning any exam feedback – whether it's praise or a pile of red corrections – into a stepping stone toward HSC success.
It can be a written comment ("Great analysis of Theme A, but need more examples for Theme B"), a number breakdown on a marking rubric for each section, or verbal notes about what you did well and where you went wrong. It also includes things like your position on the grading rubric (e.g. did your history essay meet the criteria for a Band 5 response or Band 6?), ticks and crosses, and even where the teacher deducted marks.
This feedback isn't just evaluative; done right, it's directive.
It's not just a feel-good notion that feedback helps – there's robust research behind it.
That means that, when used properly, feedback can be more effective than many hours of extra study or tuition – it's that powerful.
However (and this is a big however), not all feedback automatically produces improvement. Hattie himself emphasizes that feedback is "one of the most powerful influencers but it's also one of the most variable." If a teacher's comments are vague or if a student ignores them, the impact can be zero or even negative
Simply receiving feedback isn't enough; it's the student's response to feedback that determines whether it actually improves learning.
This is echoed by assessment experts like Royce Sadler, who argues we should be asking not "What feedback was given?" but "What did the student learn (or change) from the feedback?"Think of feedback as a dialog or a process, not a one-time event. Your exam marker is essentially starting a conversation with you about your work: "Here's what you did well; here's what needs improvement; here's how it met or fell short of the criteria."
If you continue that conversation – by reviewing, questioning, and responding through your study actions – you complete the feedback loop and reap the rewards.
Deedback only helps if you engage with it. Passively reading your teacher's notes (or worse, avoiding them) won't close the gap between where you are and where you want to be.
Finally, it's worth noting that using feedback effectively aligns with a growth mindset (more on that later). Instead of seeing your exam mark as a final judgment, you see it as "current progress" and the feedback as instructions for your next move.
Embracing feedback can be transformative: it turns mistakes into lessons, confusion into clarity, and static grades into climbing ones. Now that we know why feedback is so crucial, let's explore how you can actively use it with ten practical strategies.
The first step after getting your paper back is to decode the feedback. Start by understanding the marking criteria or rubric that your work was assessed against. In NSW, most tasks (especially in Year 11–12) come with criteria or guidelines – essentially a checklist of what the markers were looking for.
Teachers often annotate or grade different sections of your work according to these criteria.
For example, did you score 5/10 for "Analysis" or "Communication" in the rubric? Did the multiple-choice section contribute most of the lost marks, or was it the extended response? This information is gold. It tells you exactly which skill or section needs attention.
If the comment says "Evidence provided was insufficient," find the criterion about evidence/use of examples. You'll likely see that stronger responses required, say, "thorough and well-integrated evidence supporting each point." Now you know specifically what "insufficient" means – maybe you gave 2 examples when you should aim for 4, or your examples weren't detailed enough.
Similarly, if feedback says "unclear explanation of concept X," check the rubric for wording like "clarity of explanation" or "understanding of content." You probably landed in a middle band for that criterion, and the rubric's description for a higher band can hint at what was missing (for instance, a high band might require correct use of terminology and well-linked reasoning).
Why do this? Because to fix something, you need to know the standard you're trying to meet. Rubrics and marking guidelines make the teacher's expectations transparent.
In practical terms, once you understand the criteria, you can pinpoint which ones you didn't satisfy fully.
Don't forget to read through the marker's comments alongside the rubric or criteria sheet (if provided). If any criteria or comments are unclear, highlight them – you'll address those in strategy #3 (asking follow-up questions). By thoroughly understanding what the teacher is saying and why it matters for the mark, you set the foundation for all the following steps.
In short: know the rules of the game. The rubric is essentially the rulebook for scoring; your teacher's feedback is pointing out which rules you didn't fully follow. Once you see that, you can plan how to follow them better in the future.
Now that you've read the feedback and criteria, take a step back and reflect on your overall performance. This isn't about beating yourself up or gloating – it's about learning from the experience.
Identifying both strengths and weaknesses is important. The strengths tell you what to keep doing (or even do more of), and the weaknesses point to what you need to improve.
As one Australian educator put it, "Although the result attained is important, equally important is a student's ability to reflect on their performance (be it good or bad) to truly learn from the experience."
In fact, regardless of whether you topped the class or just scraped through, reflection is crucial because it allows future performance to be improved across the whole spectrum of results.
Write down one or two things that the feedback or rubric indicates you did well. Maybe your Biology teacher wrote that your experimental design was creative, or your Maths exam feedback shows you got full marks on algebra but struggled with geometry.
Next, list the key weaknesses or mistakes noted. Be specific: "didn't use enough quotes to support my argument," "misinterpreted what the essay question was asking," "made calculation errors in Q5 and Q7," "French listening section: couldn't distinguish some words."
For example: "I lost marks on the modern history source analysis because I ran out of time – maybe I spent too long on earlier questions or didn't practice timing." Or "I got several grammar errors in my Japanese writing – perhaps I need to revise those grammar rules more, or I haven't practiced writing under exam conditions enough."
Consider factors like: Was my study method effective? Did I allocate my study time appropriately across topics? Did exam nerves play a role? By asking these questions, you're performing an "exam post-mortem" (some schools call this an exam wrapper reflection).
The goal is not to dwell on what's done, but to extract lessons for next time. If you find it hard to reflect, use prompts. Some good reflection questions include: Which sections or questions did I feel most confident about, and was that confidence reflected in my marks? Which parts did I find hardest, and why? Did I manage my time well during the exam? Were there content areas I was weaker in? How did my study strategy leading up to the exam work out?
For instance, you might realize you consistently do well in multiple-choice (content knowledge is solid) but falter in long responses (perhaps an essay-writing issue). Or that you lost marks due to careless errors, which might signal rushing or anxiety.
Importantly, reflection should be constructive. It's not "I'm terrible at everything" – it's "here are two areas I want to improve and one area I did well in." This balanced approach keeps you motivated.
Remember: reflecting on how things could have gone better is much more productive than simply worrying or feeling upset about a bad mark.
By analyzing what happened, you take control of the narrative – you turn "I failed" into "I didn't do well this time because of X, Y, Z, and here's what I can do about it." That mindset shift is powerful. So take a few moments (ideally soon after getting your paper back, while it's fresh) to jot down:
This reflection will directly inform the next steps, like what questions to ask your teacher and what to target in your study. Treat each exam as a learning experience – because that's exactly what it is in the bigger picture of your HSC journey.
Feedback can sometimes be confusing or raise new questions. Maybe you don't fully understand a comment ("What did my teacher mean by 'awkward phrasing' here?") or you're not sure how to avoid a certain mistake next time. This is where following up with your teacher comes in.
Most teachers will be thrilled to discuss your performance one-on-one, because it means their feedback is sparking learning, not falling on deaf ears.
How to do it?
For example:
Teachers appreciate when you've read their feedback carefully (which you've done in steps 1 and 2) and have pinpointed exactly what you need help with. It turns the follow-up into a focused mini-tutorial, rather than a generic "how do I do better?" which is harder for them to answer.
When you sit down with the teacher, be receptive. This isn't a debate over your grade (approaching it that way rarely goes well). Instead, frame it as seeking advice. For instance:
You can even bring your self-reflection notes:
Now you're having a dialogue. Often, teachers can provide extra insight that they didn't have time to write in the margins. They might show you an example of a high-scoring response, or explain a concept in a different way that suddenly makes things click. Or they might correct a misunderstanding you had about the question. This can be incredibly enlightening.
It makes sense: if you know your teacher has high expectations and is willing to support you, you'll likely put in the effort. In fact, simply hearing something in person can carry an encouraging tone that written comments lack. For example, a teacher might say,
Feedback delivered like that feels inspiring – it tells you the teacher believes in your ability to improve.
A few tips you can use for these conversations:
If you feel the feedback you got was too brief or not helpful ("Got a B, but the teacher just wrote 'Good effort' and nothing else!"), it's absolutely fair to ask for more detail. Approach your teacher respectfully:
Teachers occasionally might skimp on detailed comments due to time constraints, but if you ask, most will gladly provide more specific guidance when prompted.
In summary, use your teachers as the valuable resources they are. Feedback can be a two-way street; your teacher gave the initial comments, and now you have the chance to respond and inquire further. This kind of follow-up not only clears up any uncertainties, it also shows your teacher that you care – which can lead to them giving you even more targeted help and maybe keeping an eye on your progress in that area in future. Don't forget to thank them for their time and advice. You'll likely walk away from such a session with newfound clarity and an action item or two – which leads us to the next step.
By this point, you should have a clear understanding of what you did wrong, what you did right, and how you could improve.
Developing a Feedback Action Plan is a great way to ensure you actually follow through on the lessons from your exam. This can be as simple as a written list of things you will do differently or practice before the next assessment, based directly on the feedback you received.
Start by summarizing the key feedback points (especially the negatives/weaknesses) into a short list. For instance, your list might say:
For example:
"Essay lacked a clear conclusion."
Read 2 sample Band 6 conclusions, then practice writing a conclusion for my last essay question.
By next Friday.
By doing this, you shift from vague intentions to specific, scheduled tasks.
Also set a timeline: what will you do weekly or by the time of the next assessment? Perhaps you'll allocate an extra half-hour twice a week to practicing the weak area, or plan a study group session to tackle difficult content together.
One useful technique is to use a template for an action plan. Some students use a simple table with columns like: Feedback Point – Action – Deadline. You might even share this plan with your teacher or a parent to keep yourself accountable.
In fact, education experts recommend exactly this approach. Creating a feedback action plan "is a useful way to help you think about how you can improve when completing future assessments". It involves reviewing your feedback, noting what to repeat or keep doing (your strengths), what to avoid or fix (your mistakes), and what specific follow-ups are needed.
Include in your plan a quick review of this feedback before your next similar assessment. For example, a week before your next exam or assignment, revisit your feedback notes and action plan to ensure you've addressed them.
This helped her focus her revision on demonstrating those elements. You can do the same: your past feedback becomes a study resource.
With an action plan in hand, it's time to put in the work – but not just any work. You want to practice in a targeted way, focusing on the weak spots identified by your feedback. Think quality and specificity, not just quantity.
Start by isolating the skill or content area you need to improve. For example, if your feedback says you need to get better at essay introductions, then practice writing introductions for various past HSC essay questions. You could take 3 different essay questions and just write the first paragraph for each, then show them to your teacher or tutor for feedback.
If the issue is a knowledge gap (say you got multiple questions wrong about a particular topic in Chemistry), then target that topic: re-read the chapter, make summary notes, and do targeted questions only on that topic until you start getting them right consistently.
Let's say your Maths exam showed you made errors in questions involving circle geometry. A targeted practice regime might be: find 10 past exam problems on circle geometry and do them over the next week, then check solutions or ask your teacher to mark them. If you get some wrong, figure out why – maybe you forgot a theorem or skipped a step in reasoning. Then practice that bit again.
Essentially, you are using your mistakes as a guide to what to practice.
When you focus practice on your weak points, you make faster improvements than if you just keep rehashing things you're already good at.
Another example: Feedback on your English Advanced essay revealed your analysis of techniques was shallow. Targeted practice could involve picking a paragraph from your essay and rewriting it with deeper analysis, or practicing on a new text in a similar way. Then maybe get a friend or teacher to quickly look at that rewrite and tell you if it's an improvement.
But also, slow practice has its place for building accuracy. If you made many careless errors in a rushed exam, take time when practicing similar questions at home to double-check each step, training yourself in the habit of verification. Then gradually add time pressure.
Don't neglect your strengths entirely – you should maintain them – but funnel extra time into your weak areas. As your essays improve, you can balance it out. Your teacher's feedback basically did you a favor by telling you where to spend your limited study time for maximum payoff. Use that intel wisely.
So when the next exam or assignment comes around, those previously troublesome parts could become areas where you gain marks instead of lose them.
Who says learning from feedback has to be a solo job? Sometimes, discussing your exam responses and feedback with classmates or friends can provide new insights and keep you motivated. Your peers are going through the same curriculum and similar assessments, so why not team up to help each other improve?
One way to leverage peers is to compare notes on feedback. For example, you and a friend both did the same exam; maybe you lost marks on different sections. By talking about it, you might discover something:
Meanwhile, your friend might ask,
This kind of exchange can reveal strategies or understandings that you might have missed. Perhaps your friend interpreted an exam question correctly that you misunderstood – their explanation could prevent you from making a similar misinterpretation next time. Or you might find that you both struggled with Question 7, so you work together to figure it out.
Another powerful peer activity is peer review of each other's work. Let's say you got an assignment back; you could swap papers with a classmate and read each other's feedback. Sometimes, seeing someone else's work and comments helps clarify what a good answer looks like versus a weaker one. You might recognize mistakes in their paper that you also made, reinforcing the lesson, or get inspired by a strength of theirs.
If your teacher said your report lacked evaluation, and your friend's feedback said they did well in evaluation, ask them to critique your attempt at rewriting that section.
Study groups can also collectively discuss tricky feedback. Maybe a bunch of you found the wording of a particular exam question confusing. Discussing it as a group can help you all understand it better – one of you might have figured out what it was really asking. Or if a concept was broadly poorly answered, group members can pool knowledge to master it together.
When engaging in peer feedback, keep it positive and supportive. The goal isn't to critique each other harshly, but to help everyone improve. Share tips that worked for you, and be open to suggestions.
Also, consider group study of model answers. Each person might notice different aspects – one sees the strong vocabulary, another sees the logical flow, another notes how thoroughly the question was answered. Combine those observations and you all walk away with a better idea of how to meet the standard.
One caution: make sure the peer advice you follow is accurate. While peers can provide great support, they're not always correct. If unsure, always double-check with a teacher. Ideally, peer discussions supplement teacher feedback, not contradict it.
It's never fun to read a critique of your work. Harsh or critical feedback can sting – "weak analysis," "many grammatical errors," "incomplete reasoning" – and it's easy to let those comments deflate your confidence. But here's the thing: every piece of negative feedback is really an opportunity in disguise. The key is adopting the right mindset.
With a growth mindset, you treat setbacks and critiques as fuel for growth, not proof of failure. Renowned psychologist Carol Dweck found that students who believe their intelligence or skills can be developed (i.e. those with a growth mindset) outperform those who believe their abilities are fixed. They are more willing to embrace challenges, persist through difficulties, and learn from criticism.
In fact, John Hattie notes that "feedback thrives on errors and mistakes. If you don't make a mistake, feedback is useless… In great classrooms, they're full of errors". Mistakes show that you're stretching beyond your comfort zone.
One trick is to rewrite negative comments as positive goals. For example, "unclear writing" becomes "Goal: work on clarity – e.g. use shorter sentences and precise terms." "Insufficient evidence" becomes "Goal: include at least 2 pieces of evidence for each point next time."
This ties in with the action plan from step 4, but it's also a mental reframing exercise. Another aspect is emotional. It's okay to feel disappointed or upset when you get a bad result or tough feedback – that's human. But don't let it simmer too long. Channel it. Some students find it motivating to say, "I'll show them!" – as determination to prove to themselves (and the teacher) that they can rise above.
As Dweck puts it, the growth mindset helps students "thrive on challenges and setbacks on their way to learning". So view your feedback as part of the challenge that will ultimately make you better.
It can also help to recall times you did improve after working on something. Maybe in Year 10 you struggled with speeches but then practiced a lot and did well in Year 11. Those experiences prove that effort leads to progress.
With a growth mindset, you'll find that what once were weaknesses can become new strengths over time. You develop resilience, because you see setbacks as temporary and fixable.
Improvement is a journey, and it's important to track your progress as you implement changes based on feedback. Why? Because seeing your growth (or lack thereof) provides feedback to yourself on what's working. It also keeps you motivated – small wins over time add up and can really boost your confidence.
This could be a section in your notebook, a Word/Google doc, or even a spreadsheet. Each time you get an assessment back, jot down: the subject, the task, your mark/grade, and key feedback points (both good and bad). Then, crucially, leave a column or space to later write what you did about it and what the outcome was in the next similar task.
By doing this, you create a narrative of your improvement. If Term 2 test still had issues, you'd log those and continue. Over the year, you can actually see the pattern of your marks and skills trending upwards (hopefully!).
You should also track progress in specific targets. Remember those goals in your action plan? Keep an eye on them. If your goal was "include 2 pieces of evidence per paragraph," check your next essay – did you do it? If yes, did it help improve the mark?
For HSC students, tracking is especially beneficial because the HSC content builds up and skills carry over. If you corrected an issue in your Year 11 final exam, you don't want to forget that lesson by the time the HSC trials or finals come – tracking helps you remember what you've learned about your own learning.
Moreover, celebrating progress is important for morale. When you track and see improvement, acknowledge it! Give yourself a pat on the back or treat yourself in some small way when you hit a milestone (like the first time you score a Band 6 in an essay after working on feedback from Band 4, or even raising a D to a C).
In case progress isn't linear and you have a dip, tracking helps there too. You can analyse what happened – was it a tougher exam? Did you neglect some feedback? Or was it just a bad day? Then you adjust and keep going.
Sometimes, despite your best efforts using teacher feedback, you might find you need a bit more help to make the jump in improvement. And that's perfectly okay! Recognizing when to seek additional resources or tutoring is a smart strategy, not a sign of defeat. It means you're committed to overcoming your weak areas by using every tool available.
For instance, if your feedback consistently says "needs more sophisticated analysis" and you're not sure what that looks like, an experienced tutor or a high-achieving peer could show you concrete examples and techniques beyond what you got in class. Or maybe your teacher's explanations didn't quite click for you on a certain topic – a different perspective from a textbook, online video, or tutor might do the trick.
When self-resources aren't enough or you want personalised guidance, seeking a tutor can be extremely beneficial. A tutor (whether a professional, a teacher offering extra sessions, or a top student/graduate) can give you one-on-one feedback and instruction targeted to your needs.
You can literally show them your marked exam and say, "These are the areas I need to work on," and they can tailor lessons to address those.
For example, at a tutoring centre, students often bring in their school assessments – tutors go through the teacher's comments with them, re-teach any concepts missed, and practice similar questions together. This kind of targeted intervention can fast-track improvement because it's intensive and individualised.
Maybe your feedback was decent, but you want to excel (turn that Band 5 into a Band 6).
In summary, don't hesitate to reach out for extra help. It's a proactive step that many successful students take. There's a reason so many high achievers in the HSC mention having attended some form of tutoring or used extra materials – it can provide that edge and clarity needed to significantly lift your performance. You're still the one doing the hard work, but a good tutor or resource is like a guide shining a light exactly where you need to focus.
We touched on mindset in step 7 when discussing turning negatives into positives, but it's such a crucial element of using feedback effectively that it deserves its own emphasis. Your mindset – how you perceive your abilities and the feedback itself – will largely determine how much you improve.
A fixed mindset is when you think your intelligence or talent in a subject is fixed ("I'm just naturally bad at science" or "I'm a math person, not a humanities person"). With this mindset, feedback can feel threatening, because it's seen as evidence of innate ability (or lack thereof).
In contrast, a growth mindset is the belief that abilities can be developed with effort, good strategies, and help from others. If you have a growth mindset, you view feedback as helpful input for your learning journey, not a final judgment on your worth or potential.
They embrace challenges because they understand that struggling with something is often the path to mastery.
Because students with a growth mindset consistently outperform those with a fixed mindset in the long run. They are more resilient – a necessary trait in the tough HSC year – and they use feedback more effectively.
In sum, maintain a perspective that ability is not fixed. Your HSC results are not predetermined by some innate trait – they are in your hands to mold through hard work and smart use of feedback.
With each assessment, focus on growth: measure how far you've come as much as the distance to your goal.
To wrap up our discussion on leveraging feedback, here's a quick list of Do's and Don'ts to keep you on track:
Feedback is often called a "gift," and while it might not always feel like one (especially when it highlights our mistakes), it truly is a powerful tool for any student aiming to improve. By actively engaging with teacher and marker feedback – understanding it, reflecting on it, seeking clarification, and then methodically acting on it – you can transform your learning outcomes.
Feedback is crucial because it shines a light on exactly what you need to do to improve.
Don't ignore feedback, don't take it as a personal judgment, and don't stick to a passive mindset.
Using feedback is an active process. We covered 10 strategies – from deciphering rubrics and reflecting, to making action plans, practicing weak areas, leveraging peers, and adopting a growth mindset.
Mindset and resilience matter at every step. Keeping a growth mindset makes you more likely to use feedback effectively.
Real students have done it, and so can you: from Alice's essay turnaround to Ben's calculus breakthrough, the formula of feedback + action = improvement is proven.
Over time, as you apply these strategies, you'll likely notice not only higher marks, but also a change in how you approach learning. You become more self-aware, more proactive, and more confident.
That transformation – from seeing feedback as a threat to embracing it as a tool – can significantly reduce stress and improve your academic journey.
Now that you're equipped with these strategies, it's time to put them into practice. Don't wait – apply this approach to your very next assessment. When you get that exam or assignment back, try at least a few of the steps outlined above. You'll likely find that taking action on feedback gets easier each time, and the results will encourage you to keep at it.
If you're looking for more guidance or feel you need personalised support in implementing your feedback, consider reaching out for extra help. This could mean speaking to a mentor or counselor at school about study strategies, or joining a study skills workshop.
Visit HSCprep Tutoring to find out how we can support you in the final steps of your HSC journey and help you achieve your personal best on exam day. You've got this – and we've got your back!